Insolvency Law – To Protect The Dignity, Not The Debt

BACKGROUND
Ever since the personal insolvency provisions of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“IBC” or the “Code”) were brought into force for personal guarantors to corporate debtors with effect from December 01, 2019, experts have expressed differing views on them, and the National Company Law Tribunal (“NCLT”), the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (“NCLAT”) and the Supreme Court of India have delivered a series of judgments some being favourable and some not so favourable to the personal guarantors, who in most cases are the erstwhile promoters of the defaulting companies. The Supreme Court upheld the 2019 notification (IBBI Official Notification S.O. 4126(E) dated November 15, 2019) in Lalit Kumar Jain v. Union of India (2021) and the constitutional validity of Sections 95 to 100 of the Code in the case of Dilip B. Jiwrajka v. Union of India (2023); earlier, in State Bank of India v. V. Ramakrishnan (2018), it had held that the moratorium protecting a corporate debtor does not extend to its personal guarantors. The law on the subject is, therefore, no longer in its infancy. Yet it has taken a single high-profile case to bring it to the attention of the general public.
The personal insolvency proceedings initiated against Mr. Subhash Chandra, founder of the Essel Group, have brought the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“Code”), back into the public discourse. Enacted nearly a decade ago, the Code is now attracting considerable attention across social media, television and mainstream print media, with several newspapers also examining its implications in their editorial columns. The proceedings, initiated by Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited under Section 95 of the Code and admitted by the NCLT in April 2024, took a dramatic turn on August 25, 2026, when a third Member of the Tribunal to whom the matter had been referred under Section 419(5) of the Companies Act, 2013 after a split verdict of the Division Bench in September 2025 approved a repayment plan under Section 114 of the Code. The plan, as reported, provides for payment of a little over Rs. 6.5 crore (Rs. 6.25 crore to creditors and Rs. 25 lakh towards process costs) against admitted claims of about Rs. 22,006 crores a haircut of close to 99.97 per cent for the creditors, many of whom are public sector banks and financial institutions. Within a week, the original Bench held that no majority view had emerged from the three opinions, and the President of the NCLT constituted a five-Member Special Bench which, on September 01, 2026, stayed the approval, restrained the guarantor from alienating his assets and fixed the matter for hearing a fresh on September 23, 2026.
Currently, the appeals by dissenting creditors are pending before the NCLAT, the guarantor has questioned the very constitution of the larger Bench, and the CBI has since registered an FIR on a creditors’s complaint alleging that inflated net worth certificates were used to obtain loans backed by his guarantee. Mr. Chandra, for his part, maintains that he never borrowed personally, that he stood only in the capacity of the guarantor for borrowings of group entities, and that the claim figure represents claims filed rather than debt owed by him.
As I understand it, the commentators’ approach has been more emotional and political than legal, driven by the sheer size of the debt owed to public sector lenders as well as private ones proposed to be extinguished, where Mr. Chandra was only the common personal guarantor for various corporate entities that borrowed for business purposes. Two points are lost in the noise, first, a repayment plan under Part III of the Code, even if approved, settles only the guarantor’s liability; the borrowing companies and the securities held from them remain available to the lenders and secondly, large amounts of debt have been wiped out in many other cases too against corporate entities through resolution plans or liquidation, and against their personal guarantors. Data from, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (“IBBI’s”) (up to June 2026) shows that creditors have realised about Rs. 4.35 lakh Crore under 1,484 approved resolution plans roughly 30 per cent of their admitted claims, though about 167 per cent of liquidation value while the 1,757 companies that were liquidated carried claims of about Rs. 5.11 lakh crore against assets valued at barely Rs. 0.22 lakh crore; recoveries from personal guarantors, though rising, remain minimal. Substantial write-offs are not the exception in insolvency proceedings; they are the norm.
Since the matter is yet to attain judicial finality, this article refrains from analysing the merits of the conflicting NCLT opinions. Conflicting orders whether by Benches in different jurisdictions or by dissenting opinions within the same Bench are part of the judicial churn by which the correct position of law is eventually settled, and some degree of uncertainty in interpretation will always exist while that process runs its course.
What this article attempts is to examine the concept of insolvency of the corporate borrower as much as of its guarantor and the role of the guarantee in corporate financing, based on my personal experience and understanding of project financing in India and abroad.
ROLE OF THE GUARANTEE
There is no doubt that, in law, a contract of guarantee is an independent contract. Under Section 128 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (“Contract Act”) the liability of the surety is co-extensive with that of the principal debtor, and a creditor may proceed against the guarantor without first initiating recovery action against the principal borrower. In return, Section 140 of the Contract Act invests the guarantor who pays with all the rights of the creditor against the principal debtor the right of subrogation.
In practice, however, project finance appraisals rest on the strength of the borrowing entity, its business model and its projected cash flows, and not on the debt-servicing capacity of the guarantors. The guarantee is taken as a comfort, not as a source of repayment.
RISK MITIGATION
The real purpose of stipulating personal guarantees and a pledge of shares from the promoters is to mitigate the risk of a change of management control of the borrowing entity during the implementation and operation of the project. The promoters bring in the equity, hold the majority of the shares and give the guarantees; the creditors want the entity to remain in their hands, with their commitment to implement and operate the project intact. That is why, in project finance, lenders generally do not take a mortgage of the personal assets of the guarantors or promoters. The financing is cash-flow based; the primary security is the cash flow and the assets of the borrowing entity, ring-fenced through a special purpose account the Trust and Retention Account.
Net worth statements of guarantors obtained at the time of the guarantee do not, by themselves, mitigate the risk of default unless they are verified at sanction and re-verified periodically thereafter. A net worth statement without due diligence on the guarantor’s assets, and without a mortgage, security bond or negative lien undertaking over those assets (preferably registered), is of little help when the time for recovery comes. The allegation now under investigation in the Subhash Chandra matter that net worth certificates running into tens of thousands of crores were furnished to a lender in 2018, while a net worth of a few crores was declared in the insolvency proceedings in 2024 is, if established, a stark illustration of that gap.
COMEDY OF ERRORS
Debt and default management in India resembles Shakespeare’s “The Comedy of Errors”, in which the merchant Egeon is condemned to death not for any wrongdoing but merely for being a Syracusan found within the walls of Ephesus, whose law forbade his presence. The personal guarantor’s position is much the same. He is liable under the law to pay the debt of the borrower; once a resolution plan for the borrower is approved, he remains liable the Supreme Court held in Lalit Kumar Jain that approval of a plan does not ipso facto discharge the guarantor while the borrower’s own liability is extinguished on the “clean slate” principle. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026 has now codified that principle, expressly preserving claims against guarantors and promoters while extinguishing the guarantor’s right of subrogation; and with effect from May 26, 2026 the personal guarantor no longer enjoys even the interim moratorium under Section 96 of the Code upon filing of an application. The guarantor thus pays a debt that no longer exists against the debtor, and cannot step into the creditor’s shoes to recover what he has paid.
DEBT AND DEFAULT MANAGEMENT
Bilateral recovery action against the company and its guarantors has generally been the creditors’ last resort and more often painful than remedial. No effective recovery has been achievable either through the Debts Recovery Tribunals or through the sale of secured assets under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (“SARFAESI”). In most cases, recovery is a never-ending process despite statutory timelines as short as 180 days under the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993 (“DRT Act”).
Since no corporate borrower is immune from default, for varied reasons, all guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank of India (“RBI”) on the subject including those on non-performing assets (“NPAs”) and the Prudential Framework for Resolution of Stressed Assets of 2019 are directed at the management of “debt and default”. The Asset Reconstruction Companies (“ARCs”) set up under SARFAESI, and more recently the National Asset Reconstruction Company Limited, are steps in the same direction: they manage the default; they do not resolve the insolvency.
CULTURE OF INSOLVENCY
The older laws were built around recovery. Because of an inadequate legal framework and the huge pendency in civil courts and tribunals, they failed to achieve the object for which they were enacted to give creditors a remedy other than protracted bilateral recovery action and in the end creditors were left to realise depressed values from the assets of debtors after a long process of identifying, attaching and selling those assets. To create a positive culture in the credit ecosystem, the Government of India enacted the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, consolidating the law of insolvency and bankruptcy hitherto scattered across the Presidency-Towns Insolvency Act, 1909, the Provincial Insolvency Act, 1920, the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (“SICA”) and the winding-up provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 (“Companies Act”), and introducing new concepts – the moratorium, the resolution professional, the committee of creditors and the time-bound process.
DOCTRINE OF INSOLVENCY – NO STIGMA
Insolvency law rests on a simple philosophy: it protects the Dignity, Not the Debt. In the short run the creditors appear to be the losers; in the long run the national economy grows, because capital and enterprise are redeployed for the benefit of all stakeholders. The Code therefore replaced the old regime with a mechanism that gives a third party one that may be in a better position to operate the insolvent entity the opportunity to do so, while creditors take their credit decisions on the strength of their own “Commercial Wisdom” within a time-bound framework. The Supreme Court has repeatedly affirmed that the Code is not a mere recovery legislation for creditors (Swiss Ribbons v. Union of India, 2019) and that the commercial wisdom of the committee of creditors is not open to judicial second-guessing (K. Sashidhar v. Indian Overseas Bank, 2019; Essar Steel, 2019). There are still few dedicated and specially trained tribunal members who appreciate that the Insolvency Mechanism is not a recovery action but a resolution process. Under this mechanism, creditors and debtors get an opportunity to settle the debt in a dignified manner. Both sides sacrifice the debtor by giving up assets and control, the creditors by taking a haircut so that the business can be revived, and neither carries a stigma out of the process.
CONCLUSION
The object of the insolvency mechanism was never and is not to provide an alternative method of recovering debt. Yet creditors, courts and tribunals approach insolvency proceedings with a “recovery of debt” mindset and apply the law accordingly. A low recovery through the insolvency mechanism is therefore always treated as a loss to creditors rather than as the closure of a recovery problem, without appreciating that the mechanism gives both creditor and borrower the opportunity to re-engage in economic activity, wiser for their past experience.
The culture of insolvency is yet to develop in Indian society to the point where the philosophy of the law is understood that it protects the Dignity of the individual, not the Debt of the creditor.
Thanks to the controversy in the Subhash Chandra matter, a Code that has been on the statute book for a decade has become known to the masses through social media. The time has come to open the insolvency route to small debtors as well. The personal insolvency provisions of the Code are in force only for personal guarantors to corporate debtors; the Fresh Start Process under Sections 80 to 93, meant precisely for small debtors, and the insolvency and bankruptcy provisions for other individuals and partnership firms remain un-notified even today, and the century-old Acts of 1909 and 1920 continue to govern such persons. The Government needs to bring the remaining provisions of Part III of the Code into force, with the Debts Recovery Tribunals adequately equipped for the purpose, so that small debtors too can avail of this route and protect their dignity.
-By ISHTIAQ ALI
Managing Partner of Orbit Law Services
The author has more than 4 decades of experience in recovery of debts both as the inhouse lawyer of public financial institution as well as he is a practising lawyer specialized in banking and finance. In case of any clarifications, please feel free to contact the author at ishtiaq.ali@orbitlaw.co.in
DISCLAIMER:
This is issued in the general interest of our clients. The views and opinions expressed herein are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of the Firm. Nothing contained herein is, purports to be, or is intended as legal advice and an independent legal advice should be sought before you act on any information or view expressed herein. No recipient of this write up should construe this alert as an attempt to solicit business in any manner whatsoever.
For any further clarifications you may get in touch with our managing partner
Mr. Ishtiaq Ali – ishtiaq.ali@orbitlaw.co.in or
our joint-managing partner Mr. Damodara Rao – damodara.rao@orbitlaw.co.in